1. Do you think that Tree-ear should have told Min about Kang's pottery? Why or why not?
2. In what ways might Min have already begun teaching Tree-ear to become a potter? Please explain your answer.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
January 2013
Our third graders are reading the book Poppy by AVI and completing a literature circle to share their insights about this wonderful story.
This is the first time these students have worked with a blog, they are doing wonderful!
This is the first time these students have worked with a blog, they are doing wonderful!
Follow Us
13 comments:
No because Tree-ear was not even supposed to know.It was none of his buisness and he really should not tell Min.
Min has kind of helped Tree-ear because now he knows how to cut and drain clay.He also has learned alot about celadon and pottery.
FBK
1.I think he shouldn't tell Min because Min would most likley get mad about Kang being secritive about his pots and Min might get jealouse.Like the old saying what gose on in this area stays in this area.
2.Min made Tree-ear cut wood so Tree-ea can have hand and eye cordination.Tree-ear cuts clay co he could learn how to cut clay evenly so he could make pots evenly.
vsw
1. I think he should not have told Min because Tree-ear was not even supposed to know. If Kang was trying to do something secretive, then Min would have probably gotten really mad at Kang for not telling him about it.
2. He is teaching Tree-ear to make the Celedon glaze. Min is also teaching him how to be a perfectionist because he keeps on telling Tree-ear to refine the glaze further over and over again.
Blue.
1.No because I think that Kang`s pottery is his buisness and also Tree-ear shouldn`t of been spying on him at all.
2.I think that he has been teaching him by chopping the wood and collecting the clay because Tree-ear will have to do that everyday if he becomes a real potter. MAS
1.No because it would have not been any of his buisness so he should not tell min.
2.I think that min has been teaching Tree-ear how to make a pot because he has been teaching him how to make clay,when he was having him stir the mud that might have been helping him with hand contral.
jc
1.I think Tree-ear should have told Min about Kang's pottery.Because maybe Kang is making more money than the two of them.
2.Maybe Min wants Tree-ear to do minor chores.Then he will teach him how to make a pot.
B.C.
1. I do not think that he should have told him about the pot, because that pot was none of his bisness.
2. Yes, Min has been teaching Tree-ear about pottery already because he knows how to cut and drain clay. He also knows how to cut the wood and he is good as it.
IKE
KC
I think Tree-ear should have told Min about Kang's pottery because I think Kang is almost clearly a better potter than Min. But, Tree-ear might end up being a potter, and one better than Kang, at that. I think Min has begun teaching Tree-ear to be a potter because potters have to take wood to the kiln and also show patience. Min might have been an assistant at one time, too.
I don't think so.It wasn't his business.2.Min has been teaching Tree-ear.He is teaching him skills.He is telling him what he would need to do if he was a potter. Jenny
1.NO!!! I think he should not tell Min because he might tell Kang. then Kang could sue Tree-ear for watching his work WITHOUT permission.
2.YES!!! He has taught Tree-ear many usefull skills( for example cutting and draining clay.)
A.D.M. from P.H.
He shouldn't because if he did Min might think he likes Kang better then his own master.
He has because Tree-ear has wached him alot, and he knows how to drain clay.
Veronica
1No, because that would be untruthful and not to tree-ear's character.
2Min was teaching Tree-ear by making him dig and sieve clay
trlh
IL
No because Tree-Ear spied on Kang making pottery and it's worse to tell Min.They might be enemies on making pottery
Post a Comment